The Subversive Theology of Imam Rauf

by Samir Selmanovic on August 24, 2010

~ by Todd Gitlin, a professor of journalism and sociology and chair of the Ph. D. program in Communications at Columbia. His next book, The Chosen Peoples: America, Israel, and the Ordeals of Divine Election (written with Liel Leibovitz), will be out in September.

The fervent mosque-haters have this much right: Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf, the Sufi leader of the Cordoba Initiative that plans to build an Islamic center on Park Place near the site of the World Trade Center, is subversive. But what he wants to subvert is not the United States of America. What he wants to subvert are dictatorships in Islamic nations.

Imam Rauf’s third book, published in 2005 but unavailable to me last week when I wrote about him and his earlier work, is called What’s Right with Islam is What’s Right with America. In these pages, Rauf proves just as Islamic as his detractors say. He is downright idealistic about Islam and hearty about its prospects. He has been scouting out America for a long time. And what is it that he finds here to gladden his Islamic soul? It’s right there on p. 176:

“…the American Declaration of Independence and Constitution.”

The imam goes on to say that these documents “express the Islamic ideal, which is itself but an expression of the Abrahamic ethic.” Yes, “the American Constitution and system of governance uphold the core principles of Islamic law.” And here’s a way of putting it that never tempted Sarah Palin or Newt Gingrich: “The overarching American religion that all Americans live under is ‘Islamic’ in the sense that it is fully compliant with and expresses the Islamic Shariah.” In Rauf’s understanding, Sharia is predicated on religious pluralism, which is “a fundamental human right under Islamic law.”

In fact—don’t tell Sean Hannity—it’s too late to resist. Satan is well ensconced here. “America is substantively an ‘Islamic’ country, by which I mean a country whose systems remarkably embody the principles that Islamic law requires of a government.”

No wonder the Imam is at this moment lecturing in the Gulf States on the State Department’s dime, to discuss “Muslim life in America and religious tolerance,” according to the AP—a trip that Governor Tim Pawlenty, guzzling a lot of tea in a hurry, calls “disgusting.”

No wonder the Bush State Department made similar use of him to win hearts and minds. He’s promoting the American social and political system. He believes that “democracy and liberty, in a peculiarly American way, provide a manifestation of the Abrahamic ethic.” If Muslims outside America “recognize in the American form of governance a genuine substantive workable expression and model of their centuries-old longing for the kingdom of heaven on earth,” he continues, “they can formulate their understanding of an Islamic state along these lines.” In other words, he wants to Americanize the Muslim world in the way that counts—by promoting our political institutions. You can see what Republicans object to, though: He says nothing about promoting the filibuster or repealing the Fourteenth Amendment.

Imam Rauf’s revisionism extends so far as to trash most putatively Islamic states—since 656 C.E., that is, when “the Muslims succumbed to dynastic rule, a paradigm of governance that did not display Islamic religious values.” No wonder it’s been a rough 13+ centuries for Islam ever since. But the moment, he argues, is ripe for American Muslims, for “no contradiction exists between Islam’s theology and the longing of many Muslims for democratic values and equality of opportunity. … Islam’s theology and jurisprudence demand it.” That is, the American system is the answer to an Islamic prayer.

The book closes with an appendix containing a fatwa issued by five Muslim clerics on September 27, 2001, at the request of the most senior Muslim chaplain in the American armed forces. Ending his book with a fatwa! Yes! Cunningly, it’s a “Fatwa Permitting U. S. Muslim Military Personnel to Participate in Afghanistan War Effort.”

What’s Right with Islam, by the way, was published by HarperSanFrancisco, which last I looked is owned by Rupert Murdoch.

Does he know what kind of poison bears his imprimatur?

{ 4 comments }

My Tiny Tiny Contribution to the Truth About Imam Feisal

by Samir Selmanovic on August 23, 2010

“Dueling Protests over Ground Zero Mosque” CBS Evening News today comes with my tiny tiny contribution to the truth about Imam Feisal (BTW, my 15 sec of fame came out of a 30 min interview). The whole story is that Imam Feisal is a wonderful man and that Muslims had their mosque in the area even before the WTC was there. They are innocent people. Please friends ponder that. Innocent. Their expulsion from the neighborhood would be a terrible mistake.

{ 0 comments }

Characters From My Book: “The Witch”

by Samir Selmanovic on August 10, 2010

Over the years I have managed to collect pictures with most of the characters from my book.  Here is the photo of Sue Lee and her son Tristan and an excerpt from  “It’s Really All About God.”

Remembering good old times with Sue and Tristan at a recent birthday party in Korea Town, year 2010.

- – – book excerpt – – –

On a cold Saturday morning in December 2001, Soo Lee waited for her already-late friend on a busy street corner in Manhattan. She discovered she was standing in front of the doors of an old limestone church off Park Avenue where I was the pastor. Its large red doors were symbols of the large hands of God embracing everyone who ventured inside. That’s what God was all about, I thought—inviting people in.

For Soo and most of her friends, church was a treacherous place. But the cold was biting, and the doors were unlocked. It was Christmas, and I had titled my sermon “The Magic of Christianity.” Soo was a lively and tender young Korean woman who followed the spiritual path of White Magic and the Wicca religion, and the words “magic” and “Christianity” together drew her from the foyer into the sanctuary. She sat and listened to a story about a stable in Bethlehem, a magical moment in human history when, as Christians believe, the physical world as it appears to us humans and the spiritual world of God’s Kingdom—the world as it really is—interpenetrated and became one.

Soo, as I later learned, is a person of uncommon stamina, a single mom, an urbanite who had learned to handle the grind of New York City with the smile of a marathon runner who has found a groove in the midst of pain. My wife and I loved spending time with her. We liked the way she thoughtfully constructed her sentences. We liked the way she paid attention to what we didn’t say as much as to what we said. And we liked the way she treated everyone and everything around her. With compassion. Over the next several months, Soo and her little son, Tristan, became family friends. Soon we were caring for her boy and she was caring for our little daughters.

Some months after we met Soo, my church hosted the annual gathering of a national network I belonged to that consisted of mostly professional clergy and church leaders. The main service was going to include a closing segment we titled “Testimonies of Failure,” with six leaders who would tell us how they had failed in their religious work. It was not to be “how God turned things around for me” or “how my failure has actually been a blessing.” There would be no explanations, no justifications—just standing up, sharing the misery, and sitting down. I had a month to find someone who could address these hurting people with some healing words.

I thought of people who had cared for and encouraged me, and Soo immediately came to mind. But the thought seemed preposterous. Soo? How could I ask a witch to pray over a group of pastors? She could neither defend nor advocate for our religion—she was an outsider. But the experience of being a part of Soo’s life had opened a crack in the wall that separates “us” (those on the inside) from “them” (those on the outside). Then a thought broke through, a possibility that I found both burdensome and exhilarating. What if God is on the outside too? Does God have to be absent out there in order to be present in here?

The thought of inviting Soo into the inner sanctum of our Christian experience ripened like wine, intoxicating my orthodox faith. Everything I had been taught told me that God, in God’s infinite wisdom and love, has chosen to dwell in our religion. It was a kind of certainty one can stake one’s life on. But then everything I had experienced with Soo—and, as I began recalling, others like her over the years—told me that God dwells in the lives of people. All people. Drunk with these thoughts, I hesitated. Which should win? Religion? Or life? Should I use life to prop up my religion? Or should I use my religion to honor life?

“Okay, I’ll do it,” Soo said with a smile when I asked her. Then she added, “But only if I can pray to God as Mother.”

“Soo,” I said, and paused, taking time to swallow a momentary feeling of regret for approaching her at all, “some of these religious leaders are worn out and beaten down, and on that day, our goal is not to expand their theology but to comfort them.”

“I understand, Pastor Samir. That’s all right. For now. Let’s leave the discussion about the Christian obsession with phallic power for some other time,” she said with a gracious smile. “Is it okay if I pray to God as Holy Spirit?”

“Wonderful,” I said, relieved.

On the day of the gathering, after the six “losers” had shared their stories, the congregation was quiet, stunned by tales of the stark reality behind much of religious work and community organizing. Most of us religious people who go to our places of worship to receive religious goods and services assume that our faith is triumphantly marching forward on all fronts. Nobody wants to be a part of a losing battle. So talking about failures devoid of happy endings created an unbearably empty space in our hearts.

The sacred Scriptures say that in emptiness, God creates.

Then it was Soo’s turn to pray. After introducing her to the crowd, I stepped aside, regretting my choice again, my jaws tightening, my palms sweating. How did I get myself into a situation of bringing a witch to bless a conservative Christian crowd? Did I want to lose my job?

Or was I heeding the call of Jesus—losing my life in order to find it?

With the steady voice of a person who has no doubts that our ordinary lives are saturated with the Presence, she said, “Dear Holy Spirit, I am not a Christian. But I and my son are cared for in this church. These people who follow you work very hard to make a difference in the world and love people like us. Now they are tired, disoriented, discouraged. Please, make them see how important their work really is. What would our world be without people like them? Help them continue caring so that people like me might find a better way.”

There are religious experiences that have the power to restart our hearts, when fresh faith in God, humanity, and world is uploaded into our soul systems. This was one of those moments. A hush fell over the crowd, and Soo’s words lingered in the air like a sweet heathen scent. While some sat there paralyzed by the offense of her presence at the church pulpit, many of us basked in her compassion for us. We were hoping that if we just stayed quiet, there would be more words from her, interceding to our God on our behalf.

Life won.

After the crowd dispersed, I sat on a pew in the empty sanctuary to jot down these words in my notebook: “We are scared of finding our God in the other. Why do we fear something so wonderful?”

{ 1 comment }

Why Christians Need Places Like Faith House (by Ryan Bell)

by Samir Selmanovic on August 3, 2010

~ by Ryan Bell who is the Senior Pastor of the Hollywood Seventh-day Adventist Church. You can learn more by reading his blog, Intersections.

Why should Christians participate in the Faith House project?  I believe that Jews, Muslims, atheist, and others will each generate solid reasons for their participation.  Such reasons will be rooted in their story/worldview. For us Christians, it is the incarnation that can most powerfully and creatively shape our imagination towards an answer.

For generations missionaries from the West (the US, UK, Australia & New Zealand) have entered communities of people profoundly different from themselves. These missionaries were taught to enter these communities as learners. This learning encompassed everything from language to food to social norms. Our short hand for this is “culture.” In short, these missionaries knew they were entering a world of which they had almost no understanding. As they learned about the people to whom God had sent them they were engaging the profound theological practice of “paying attention” – paying attention to God’s Spirit, being attentive to their own hearts and souls, and watching for evidence of God’s initiatives in the community.

Naturally, missionary engagements almost never went that smoothly. The modern missionary movement has become known for its arrogance and colonialism. Nevertheless, missiologists and responsible missionaries the world over know that they must be, at some level, anthropologists as well as theologians.

We have assumed that a learning posture toward our own native culture is unnecessary. After all, this is our home. However, as the world has come to us (especially in the urban centers) and the social fabric of Western societies has worn thin and come apart, we find ourselves in a vastly different world than that of our parents and grandparents.

In the midst of the church’s confusion about its place in this unhinged world, we are (or should be) driven back to our core narratives. And, at the very outset of those narratives we find the story of God showing up in our world at the most unlikely time and the most unlikely place. Theologians call this the Incarnation – divine become human. St. John said this about this mystery: “The Word became flesh and blood and moved into the neighborhood.”

So, the primary mission question of our time is, can we live among the people of our neighborhoods? Can we “pitch our tent” in the pluralistic village as a neighbor and learner without coming with all the answers in our pocket? Can we open ourselves to the possibility of learning as much from our neighbors as they will learn from us? My contention is that much that has passed for evangelism and/or mission work in the US and elsewhere has been shaped more by a colonial than by an incarnational imagination. It’s high time we have our imaginations shaped by the story of God’s missionary encounter with us.

Why then should those of us who are Christians participate in the Faith House project? First, to learn and to receive, and then perhaps to teach and to give.

Ways to Donate to Faith House Manhattan

{ 0 comments }

Risking More and Sooner

by Samir Selmanovic on July 27, 2010

A Letter from Samir Selmanovic as Founder of Faith House Manhattan

It was on the first anniversary of 9/11 that I made an announcement to my family and friends: “I will risk more and sooner.” I was done with my religion as usual. It dawned on me that religious zealotry cannot be fought with indifference. Extremists feeding on prejudice, legislating exclusion, and resorting to violence cannot be prevailed upon with less passion from people like you and me. Telling them to “cool down” will do nothing at all. We must allow fires greater than theirs to arise. It is our passion for a whole and interdependent world that must rise above their passion for a segregated and zero-sum world. So, when I get intimidated, despondent, or exhausted in this struggle for interdependence, I sing to myself quietly and prayerfully with a chorus of voices all over the world, “We shall overcome.”

This risk taking led me to start Faith House Manhattan, along with my wife, daughters, and many of you. Faith House is only a part of a larger movement towards interdependence; there are many visionary individuals and organizations we are learning from. Yet, Faith House is unique. It exists to make sure that people have an opportunity to experience “the other.” Inevitably, experience engenders compassion. And compassion is an uncontrollable force. It overturns our ways of thinking, it mobilizes, it changes, it sustains. And that’s what Faith House does, unleashes compassion.  

When two young men, Moez, a Muslim, and David, an Orthodox Jew, strike up a friendship by engaging in serious thinking, good humor, and mutual support before, during, and after our Living Room Gatherings, Faith House happens. When our leaders talk to groups from all over the world who come to the city to learn the ways of interdependence, like a recent group of students from Denmark, Faith House happens (next year they are bringing the teachers from their entire school region). When we bring together GreenFaith, Bill McKibben, 350-dot-org and “green” Muslims to join together in a life-sustaining event in the largest cathedral in the USA, that’s Faith House too (September 18, 2010, full details coming soon!). When we direct people to our numerous and amazing allies such as the Interfaith Youth Core in Chicago and Union Theological Seminary or Intersections International in New York, Faith House happens. When we stand for and consult with our Muslim friends in Cordoba Initiative in New York who are daring to open a new front against radicalism by building Park51, a Muslim Community Center in downtown Manhattan, serving all Americans, Faith House happens. And on and on it goes.

We bring people together and trespass imaginary boundaries while preserving the real ones, not only in New York City but nationally and internationally. But more than any programming, Faith House is you, people who understand the importance and urgency of this work. And now we need your support and call upon your vision and generosity.

We are all very busy in our own circles of belonging. We have our own people and our own affairs to take care of. Yet, the wellbeing of our own circles and our own affairs is now intertwined with the wellbeing of others. The time when we could leave issues of freedom, religion, and politics to those with the loudest voices is now over. We cannot live well if we know more about brands of consumer products than we know about the amazing treasures of history, stories, and spirituality of people who live across the street or work across the office or a members of our family. This must, can, and will change. In fact, investing in interdependence is not a risk but a safe investment into our future. A failure to invest in it would be a reckless course of action.

Please throw the indifference to the wind, like a fist of chaff. This is your world. Do so by helping visionary, persevering, effective, and resilient organizations like Faith House do the work of experimenting, discovering, learning, and teaching. Make an appropriate contribution now. By contributing, you will not only help make a material difference making sure Faith House continues to operate effectively. By contributing, you will tell us that we are doing this for you and your children too. And that will sustain us more than you will ever know.

We have set a modest goal that we have to meet in order to survive as an organization. We are one-third of the way there. Risk with us. Contribute generously now.

SEND A CHECK to “Faith House Manhattan”
PO Box 552, NY, NY 10028

GIVE ONLINE through our Fiscal Sponsor (AMM),
select “Faith House”

GIVE ONLINE through our Facebook Cause

In Faith,

Samir Selmanovic, Ph.D.
Founder and President of the Board, Faith House Manhattan

{ 0 comments }

Snoopy’s Book on Theology

by Samir Selmanovic on July 20, 2010

Do you have cartoons, videos, or other media that involves humor and theology?  I would LOVE to post it here.  Thanks.

{ 0 comments }

An increasing number of people identify with the statement, “I am spiritual but not religious.” Even many religious people don’t know exactly how we got here but we have to honor where our hearts have gone.

Religion is difficult. It has history— and every history has its dark ages or, at the very least, dark moments. And the entire world is the judge. Spirituality, on the other hand, is personal. It starts and ends with me. And I am the judge.

We know there is more to life than what we can see and touch. Our existence is mystical and not just physical. We are all made of this “spiritual stuff,” a dust that remembers its cosmic origins. No-one is spared being human, so none of us are spared from being spiritual. Spirituality is our subjective experience of the common lot of living “in between”—between dust and stardust, glory and gore, matter and spirit. Spirituality is our individual experience of the interior world we all have.

Spirituality does not have to involve religion. It is a way of traveling freely and intimately through the journey of human life, engaging with what’s found there. But, the moment two people begin conversing about the meaning of their experience—the moment they begin naming experiences, thoughts, concepts, practices, convictions, anything at all—is the moment their religion germinates. We want to communicate about and pursue together what we think matters, strive for what is good, struggle against what is bad, cling to what is real and admire what is beautiful.

And the moment a large number of people begin to want the same things and decide to help each other on their journey, we have a major religion.

Religion comes from the Latin root word religio, meaning “to bind back.” We bind ourselves to what we hold as valuable and to others who value the same thing. To thrive and make a difference, every spirituality needs a community— maybe not a church as we know it but certainly a community. In this sense, everyone has religion.

Religion will never go away, for we will always want to make our spirituality function in more than our own isolated selves. We fight over our religions because it is in religion that we fully articulate our differences. Without religion, we would be left to drift with our own meanings, isolated from each other. Without religion, nothing would be passed from generation to generation. Imagine the invention of the wheel, fire and writing, with every new generation taking up the task of inventing them again.

Spirituality, on the other hand, can be frighteningly undemanding. It can serve some kind of generic god that submits himself (or herself ) to our own egos. Such a god never cuts across our will, never confronts, never frustrates and never leads us through dark places.

But the world is often dark and, more importantly, each of us participates in making it the way it is. To change the world, one must be changed oneself, and a god who is not allowed to disagree with us cannot change us. Spirituality without religion has been as much a source of suffering as religion without spirituality.

Religion is a journey of many generations that provides us with a starting point to dig down and find the depth of our soul. Religious traditions—with their accumulated wisdom, practices and an extensive chart of wrong paths taken in the past—can help us stay “with it” until we touch the bottom.

Religion is here to stay, simply because human beings will always put their efforts together in making good— or evil—happen. But it is in a religious community that a robust personal spirituality can develop where it matters most. In community, our personal spiritualities cross pollinate with one another, and interact with the wisdom and strength handed down to us from our religious tradition. In turn, our present contribution can be shared with others in such a community and passed into the future.

To live is to be spiritual.  To live well is to be religious.

(this post is an adaptation of an article I wrote last year for Signs of the Times, Australia)

{ 0 comments }

Video: Experiencing Your Neighbor’s Faith

by Samir Selmanovic on June 16, 2010

By TheOOZEtv:

Let’s step over the threshold of “stalemate” and create new stories, says Samir Selmanovic, in an interview with ThinkFWD host, Spencer Burke. Selmanovic’s book, It’s really all about God, was born out his faith journey that began with childhood in a Muslim family where belief in God was considered a crutch, although the traditional religious holy days and celebrations were observed. When he became a Christian, he was expelled from his home and spent two years sleeping on the couches of church members who took him in. He confesses he spent many years stridently arguing for the “rightness” of his particular religious beliefs—“My beliefs are true; yours are not.”

Today, Samir encourages us to rethink our faith and move from “It’s all about me.” to “It’s all about God.” Muslim, atheist, Jew –these are adjectives to the name “Christian,” he says. Samir is part of a gathering called Faith House which invites the community to share a common space (a living room) and experience their neighbor’s faith. All of our different faiths, and the different “mysteries” that each of us are, affect each other. Learning about my neighbor’s faith and experience, allows me to see new beauty, and poses questions that help me deepen and broaden my faith.

We need to encounter brothers, neighbors, even strangers of different faiths. We need a perspective that says, “There must be more about you, about others, than just to serve MY story.” Samir says, “I cannot argue for the absence of grace and say that YOUR story must be a lie for mine to be true. We are called to judge things by their fruit. Take a close look at our theology and if it sounds reprehensible, then we need to admit that.”

For Samir, humility and hospitality IS the doctrine, the dogma, and to practice it is to go deeper, not to water down, our faith. Christianity exists to serve the Kingdom of God, not the other way around. Look around you, says Samir. The Kingdom of God is here—enter it!

For Personal Reflections and Small Group Questions click HERE.

“Experiencing Your Neighbor’s Faith” is a tagline of Faith House Manhattan. We really do this!  If you would like to help us, click HERE.

{ 11 comments }

Three Pics From the Protest

by Samir Selmanovic on June 9, 2010

On a hot Sunday, three days ago, I took my younger daughter Leta downtown to observe with me the protest held by those who oppose the Muslim Community Center. I told her that this is part of history, that in US there is always current “other” that people are taught to fear. Current position of “other” in the United States has been assigned to Muslim community. I told her that supporting them in their endeavor is an issue of human rights, and therefore our issue too, as Christians. Plus I bought her her favorite ice-cream.  We sat on a bench in a shade then took some pictures of about 300 protesters. Here is what we saw.

About 300 protesters, mostly from outside of New York, with many signs, American flags, and a line up of dozens of speakers speaking fear and asking for action.

All I need to know about Christianity I learned from KKK?

This sign does not need a comment. The Bible says, "a righteouss person does not assemble with mockers."

Dispersed among the words of fear and hate were some legitimate hurts and concerns expressed. Knowing many Muslims through my work in the city and nationally, I am utterly confident American Muslims will rise to this moment of history and make the United States an even better country than it is today.

My daughter and I stood with Jesus there. We stood shoulder to shoulder with true Muslims. And we shall not be moved.

{ 10 comments }

This article was written last summer and published in the Winter 2010 issue of the Anglican Theological Review.  It captures my thoughts about Faith House’s first year and this community’s larger contribution.  Although it was written for an Episcopal (Christian) audience, it makes central use of a text from the Qur’an and would be of interest to anyone in the Faith House and interfaith community.
* Download formatted PDF of published article, with footnotes

Anglican Theological Review
Winter 2010 • Pages 175-181
Volume 92 • Number 1

“Has the story reached thee, of the honored guests of Abraham?”

Bowie Snodgrass

Has the story reached thee, of the honored guests of Abraham? Behold, they entered his presence, and said: “Peace!” He said, “Peace!” (and thought, “These seem) unusual people.” Then he turned quickly to his household, brought out a fatted calf, And placed it before them . . . he said, “Will ye not eat?” (When they did not eat), He conceived a fear of them. They said, “Fear not,” and they gave him glad tidings of a son endowed with knowledge. But his wife came forward (laughing) aloud: she smote her forehead and said: “A barren old woman!” They said, “Even so has thy Lord spoken: and He is full of Wisdom and Knowledge.”

Holy Qur’an, Surah 51:24–30
(translated by Hafiz Abdullah Yusuf Ali)

Being a guest in the home or religious space of the “other” can be awkward. The story of the visit of the honored guests to Abraham’s tent (Gen. 18:1–15) reminds us of the awkwardness that can also accompany being a host. In Genesis, Abraham has to hurry about after offering food to the strangers, asking Sarah to make bread and the servant to hurriedly prepare a tender calf. In Surah 51 of the Qur’an, Abraham becomes fearful when the guests do not eat the slain calf. In both stories, the hostess, Sarah, laughs aloud when the guests foretell that she will bear a son.

In interfaith relations, whether we are present as guest, host, or on neutral ground, there is at first a degree of awkwardness. At Faith House Manhattan, “an experiential inter-religious community that comes together to deepen our personal and communal journeys, share ritual life and devotional space, and foster a commitment to social justice and healing the world,” we embrace the gift of encountering God in the other as “holy awkwardness” and an indispensable spiritual discipline of the twenty-first century.

TO READ THE ENTIRE ARTICLE, CLICK HERE.

{ 0 comments }